Ally's Mad Mystery

Mal
Mal has been planning for big talking Dragons concert as a secret surprise for Ben. Mal complimented Ally on her cake wishing she had Ally's culinary skills. When Ally informs the room that there was a problem and Mal asks Ally what was going on as the unofficial spokesperson for the crowd. Mal along with Evie went up on stage and comforted Ally asking if she's blowing her accusations out of proportions. Mal suggested that is she sure that someone wasn't just hungry out of pity. Mal asks Ally to come off stage and Mal reassures her with Evie's statement that this is Auradon and no one steals. Ally suggest CJ as a counter argument and Mal admits CJ is kind of a criminal but adds that CJ is off who knows where in Auradon before telling Ally she's turning little things into big deals.

Evie
Evie complimented Ally on her cake Saying it looks wicked. Evie along with Mal went up on stage and comforted Ally asking if she's blowing her accusations out of proportions.

Jay
Jay saw Ally and said hello but Ally didn't hear him for second and Jay snickered asking her if she's in Ally Land which is a term the students of Auradon uses for Ally whenever she zones out. Jay heads back to the carnivals before Audrey loses it on him but told Ally he was looking forward to her carrot cake. Jay later came over to Ally's food table wanting to try Ally's carrot cake only for it to have disappeared. Ally asks Jay to block the entrances so no one leaves or get out.

Carlos
Carlos was eating Ally's chocolate scones and complimenting her on it's good taste.

Jane
Jane was surrounded by a circle of girls admiring gold watch that is encrusted with tiny diamonds.

CJ
Ally mentions that while she didn't figure what CJ was the one who was pulling pranks on everyone because CJ revealed herself but insist that was close to figuring it out.

Audrey
Audrey complimented Ally saying that fairies couldn't even do a better job.When Ally informs the room that a thief stole the spirit weekend reception cake which causes everyone in the room to laugh Ally notes that even Audrey and Freddie are laughing at her.

Chad
Chad agreed with Carlos that Ally's scones tasted good. Someone in the crowd jokes that Chad Charming stole the cake.

Freddie
Ally mentions that while she didn't figure what was happening with Freddie's shadow cards but She accompanied Freddie and Jordan to Mama Odie's house. When Ally informs the room that a thief stole the spirit weekend reception cake which causes everyone in the room to laugh Ally notes that even Freddie and Audrey are laughing at her. When examining the culprits shadow which Jane points out the culprit didn't have a ponytail but a hat with a peacock feather and Ally thinks it's Freddie. Freddie was in her dorm having a conversation with CJ about the stuff that CJ stole, Ally and Jane were eavesdrop on the conversation which leads Ally to believe Freddie and CJ stole the cake.

Lonnie
Lonnie in the past was wearing Jordan's gold locket that she lent Lonnie and Ally had thought she stole it. Ally asks Lonnie to cut the music and Lonnie worried does what Ally asks. Lonnie couldn't keep the music off and told Ally she was sorry, but she had to keep the party going.

Jordan
When Ally and Jane come up with clue the thief is a girl with a ponytail, Ally suggests Jordan but Jane mentions Jordan wasn't at Auradon Prep this weekend because she's visiting her dad.